The White House
Office of the Press Secretary
Remarks by President Obama and President Clinton at a Campaign Event
New York, New York
5:24 P.M. EDT
PRESIDENT CLINTON: (In progress) -- and secondly, the alternative would be, in my opinion, calamitous for our country and the world. I think that he's got the right economic policies and the right political approach, and I think their economics are wrongheaded and their politics are worse.
And if you just look at -- the month he took the oath of office, we lost 800,000 jobs. In the last three and a half years, the economy has produced 4.3 million -- 27 months, really, -- 4.3 million private sector -- for the last three-and-a-half years. It is 60 percent more jobs -- listen to this -- 60 percent more private sector jobs than were created in the seven years and eight months of President Bush's administration, before the meltdown -- before the meltdown. And he did it with the so-called stimulus bill, with the automobile restructuring -- which I think is an amazing achievement -- and with a number of other things, including a serious commitment to an independent energy future and a commitment to bringing manufacturing back to this country.
And things have slowed up a little now for two reasons -- one is Europe, which is beyond our control, although he and his national security team are working hard on it. That is, the economic team is now our national security team in Europe. (Laughter.) And the other is that the Republican Congress and their nominee for President, Governor Romney, have adopted Europe's economic policy. Who would have ever thought that the Republicans who made a living for decades deriding "old Europe" would embrace their economic policy? (Laughter.) But that’s what they've done.
Their economic policy is austerity and unemployment now, and then a long-term budget that will explode the debt when the economy recovers so that interest rates will be so high nobody will be able to do anything. His economic policy is job growth now, and long-term budget restraint.
If you look at the budgets, their budgets, every one of them, all the congressional budgets and Governor Romney's add $1 or $2 trillion to the trajectory of the debt that we're on right now. His budget takes it down.
And if you look at their politics, it's constant conflict. And the only thing in the world that’s working is cooperation. When he has a free hand, he cooperates. He got labor and management together in the auto restructuring, and we've got 80,000 more people working making American cars, and saved 1.5 million jobs.
I know a lot about this -- I grew up in a car dealership. (Laughter.) I know a lot about this. We would never have heard the end of it if those two companies had failed and all those auto parts manufacturers had failed and all those dealerships had closed. It would have been a nightmare.
He got labor, management, the environmental groups and the government together on the auto-mileage standards -- you got 150,000 new jobs out of it.
Cooperation is what works. Constant conflict is a dead-bang loser. You can see it all over the world.
So the politics is wrong on the Republican side; the economics are crazy. He's got good policies. He's got a good record. He's made the best of a very challenging situation. He deserves to be reelected. And I know I don’t have to say that I think he's done an extraordinary job with the national security responsibilities of the country, both making it safer and building a world with more partners. And he had a pretty good Secretary of State, too. (Laughter and applause.)
So I thank you for being here, and I hope you will try to find simple, direct ways to say these things to your friends and neighbors. This is what's important. What happens and whether we can bring back the American Dream or not is riding on whether he wins this election in a clear and unambiguous way, and we make it clear that we want a politics of cooperation and an economics of growth and broadly shared prosperity.
President Obama. (Applause.)
PRESIDENT OBAMA: Thank you everybody. No need to -- thank you so much. Thank you. (Applause.) Thank you. Please, please.
Well, first of all, to the Lasry family, to Marc and Cathy, all the kids -- particularly Alex, who had been working with Valerie Jarrett for a while and now is off to business school -- I just want to thank them for their extraordinary friendship. They have been great supporters and great friends for a really, really long time. And so to open up their beautiful home to us and offer such great hospitality, I can't be more grateful.
To President Bill Clinton -- as usual, he pretty much summed it up. (Laughter.) So I don’t have to add too much -- don’t want to guild the lily here.
Nobody has a better grasp and understanding of the issues than this man. He spent eight years guiding this country through, initially, some difficult times, and then ushered in one of the greatest booms that we've seen -- a recipe of stable, steady growth in which everybody participated, growth that started from the bottom up and from the middle class out.
And everybody did well, including those at the top, because -- in part, because of President Clinton's background. He understood what it takes to grow this economy, that there's just extraordinary talent all across the country. In little places in Arkansas and little apartment buildings in Hawaii and -- (laughter) -- there are folks out there who are eager to live out that American Dream and create new businesses and new opportunities. And just about everybody here, somewhere in their lives they've known that when we work together we can't be stopped. And that’s what's at stake in this election, as Bill said.
I want to spend most of my time answering questions, but part of what I’m going to be doing over the next several weeks is just clarifying for people the choice involved -- because we have a fundamental choice. And the truth is it’s an argument that dates back to Bill Clinton’s presidency. As you will recall, you didn’t get a lot of cooperation out of those Republicans in Congress either. (Laughter.)
And the basic issue is after World War II, we arrived at a basic consensus in this country; it was a rough consensus between Republicans and Democrats, and there was a spectrum there, but everybody understood that the market was the best generator of wealth and opportunity that we had ever seen. It was understood that America’s business was business, that government is not the ultimate source of our wealth and our freedom. But what we also understood was that there were certain investments we had to make to create a platform for opportunity for everybody.
And so among Democrats and Republicans there was a belief in a basic social safety net. And there was a belief that regulations wouldn’t inhibit necessarily economic growth, they could actually advance them. Because the reason we had the best capital markets in the world was people trusted our capital markets, and they believed in disclosure, and they believed in transparency and openness and accountability. And so small investors and large investors said, you know what, let’s put our money in America.
And people from Richard Nixon to George H.W. Bush understood that if we have smart environmental regulations that can actually create opportunity. And if we have good consumer regulations, that actually helps America’s brand because people can trust our products and trust our services.
And there was an understanding we’re going to make an investment in education, whether the GI Bill or opening up more and more opportunity for a college education, and making sure that we’re investing in our -- the crown jewel of America’s economy, our colleges and our universities -- because we understood that that’s where innovation comes from and ultimately that’s going to create opportunity.
And we understood whether we were going to make investments in the Interstate Highway System or in DARPA that ultimately that would inure to the benefit of the marketplace.
And we understood that we had to pay for it. The notion was this stuff wasn’t going to be free. It used to be the argument between Democrats and Republicans was what’s the best way to pay for it, but we understood that ultimately these were investments worth making. And there were times where Democrats got a little excessive. We had a little too much faith in government, a little too much faith in regulation, and there was a corrective mechanism. And Bill Clinton helped to correct some of our excesses.
And we understood not every government program is going to work, and we understood that not every regulation should be command-and-control, top down; that a lot of times the market might provide -- if we provide the proper incentives, the market might come up with better solutions for how we were going to solve some of these vexing problems.
But over the last 15 years, the last 20 years, that consensus has broken down. If you look at what the Republican Party today represents -- we haven’t moved that much. If you’ve compared -- there’s a reason why Jack Lew was the OMB Director under Bill Clinton and he was my OMB Director and now my Chief of Staff. Jack hasn’t changed that much. (Laughter.) He’s gotten a little grayer. (Laughter.) Our basic policies haven’t shifted. We’ve responded to new information and new circumstances.
What’s changed is the Republican Party. They have gone from a preference for market-based solutions to an absolutism when it comes to the marketplace; a belief that all regulations are bad; that government has no role to play; that we shouldn’t simply be making sure that we balance the budget, we have to drastically shrink government, and eliminate those commitments that have ensured a middle class had a chance to succeed and to thrive for several generation.
And so if you look at Paul Ryan’s budget or you look at Governor Romney’s proposals, what they’re talking about is something that is fundamentally different from our experience in growing this economy and creating jobs. And so that’s going to be the central issue in this campaign. And we’re going to do everything we can to clarify that choice.
The good news is the American people I think agree with us. The challenge is that things have been very tough for people for the last three, four, five, 10 years. And when things are tough, you’re willing to try just about anything even if you’ve seen it before. And so what we have to do is to make sure that we’re constantly getting a clear message out about how we intend to grow the middle class, how we’re going to create jobs, and how our positions are squarely in the center of America’s traditions.
We’re not the ones who changed. And the track record that Bill Clinton mentioned is one that I’m extraordinarily proud of, but as important as the work that we’ve done over the last three and a half years has been, this is actually an election that’s going to set the stage for what we do over the next 20 or the next 30. And I want the American people to understand that.
But I think precisely because we’re right on these issues, I think we’re going to win this election. We’re just going to make -- we’re going to have to just make sure that we get our message out effectively. And that means help from all of you.
So I’m grateful for all of you being here and I’m looking forward to hitting the campaign trail hard. And luckily I’ll have some pretty good companions along the way.
Thank you. (Applause.)
5:38 P.M. EDT